Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (2024)

Home » Green Tomato Pickles – Old Retro Recipe

by Matt Dobson

What did the roast beef and cheese sandwich say to the green tomato pickles? You complete me! Or maybe that’s just a line from a bad Tom Cruise movie. Anyway, these green tomato pickles are so delicious.

I have just finished smothering a bread roll in this spicy relish and devouring it, and believe me, it really does make the sandwich complete!

This pickled relish recipe is a fabulous way to use the green tomatoes that won’t ripen at the end of the season.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (1)

There are so many traditional recipes that I remember my grandparents making when I was small. A lot of recipes like jams and relishes were used to ensure there wouldn’t be wastage when there was a huge crop of cucumbers, or the tomatoes weren’t ripening.

I have noticed a lot of these family secret recipes just don’t seem to get made anymore!

When I was younger housewives and granny’s would be making, and giving away;tomato chilli jam, chutneys, pickles, cucumber relishes and jams.

This green tomato pickles recipe is a real blast from the past. My taste buds instantly remembered the relish flavour.

It took me back to eating roast beef and cheese sandwiches at nan’s, with heaps of pickles and chunks of real butter.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (2)

So how did I come to be sharing a recipe for Green Tomato Pickles? I had just made my Tomato Chilli Chutney from the excess tomatoes in my garden and a friend commented that his mother had the best green tomato pickle recipe ever!

So Craig decided that it was timethat I should learn how to make this family recipe. We engaged the assistance of his mother Maureen to make a batch of Nana’s famous green tomato pickles.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (3)

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (4)

Green Tomato Relish Recipe [ Pickles ]- Homemade Retro Method

What did the roast beef and cheese sandwich say to the green tomato pickles? You complete me! Or maybe that's just a line from a bad Tom Cruise movie. Anyway, these green tomato pickles are so delicious.

3.65 from 42 votes

Print Pin Rate

Course: Condiment

Cuisine: American, Australian, English

Prep Time: 3 minutes minutes

Cook Time: 6 hours hours

Total Time: 6 hours hours 3 minutes minutes

Servings: 18 Jars

Calories: 18kcal

Author: Matt Dobson

Ingredients

  • 1.9 kg Green Tomatoes
  • 400 g Onion
  • 9 Tbs salt
  • 900 g sugar
  • 750 ml white vinegar
  • 1/4 cup flour
  • 3 Tbs Curry powder
  • 1 Tbs Ground Turmeric

Instructions

Day 1

  • Wash the tomatoes, remove any stalks and dry them thoroughly.

  • Chop the tomatoes and onions into a similar sized dice. In a large saucepan add a layer of 1/3 of the tomatoes and 1/3 of the onions, add 1/3 of the salt evenly over the layer.

  • Continue this process until you have three layers. Cover the saucepan and leave to stand overnight. This will draw out any moisture.

Day 2

  • Drain off all the liquid from the tomato mixture.

  • Boil a jug with hot water and pour over the tomato mixture and drain again. Do this twice to remove all the salt.

  • Put the tomatoes on the stove and add 450ml of white vinegar. Bring the mixture to the boil cover and then cook for ten minutes using a timer.

  • In the meantime in a bowl combine the flour, turmeric, and curry powder with the remaining 300mls vinegar until it becomes a paste. Reserve for later use.

  • Once the tomato has boiled for ten minutes add the sugar and stir until dissolved.

  • Turn off the heat and add the paste slowly to the tomato mixture while stirring. Avoid lumps by adding the paste slowly and continuing to stir.

  • When the paste has been fully combined, place the pickles over a low heat and simmer gently. Pickles should be cooked for another 10 minutes, or until the mixture has reached the desired consistency.

  • Remove from the heat and allow it to cool slightly before bottling in sterilized jars.

Nutrition

Serving: 30g | Calories: 18kcal | Carbohydrates: 4g | Protein: 0.5g | Fat: 0.5g | Cholesterol: 0mg | Sodium: 3489mg | Potassium: 25mg | Fiber: 0g | Sugar: 0g | Vitamin A: 10IU | Vitamin C: 0.2mg | Calcium: 10mg | Iron: 0.6mg

Out comes the Sweet Pickles old school recipe card

One of the really cute things about this recipe is that it was typed on nice little-indexed cards in pounds! We had to convert the recipe to metric as we went.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (5)

As it turns out, finding 6kgs of green tomatoes isn’t that easy, but after a trip to Ricardoes Tomatoes in Port Macquarie the vital ingredient was secured. The pickle making is a two-day process so Craig’s mother kindly offered to dedicate two days to the pickling and teaching of her recipe.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (6)

The result of all these green tomatoes would be three batches of pickle relish or about 18 jars!

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (7)

I have given the recipe for a single batch which is about six jars.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (8)

Maureen (Craig’s mum) warned us that she would be the quality controller for cooking this recipe.

Unless each green tomato pickle batch all past the taste test they wouldn’t be allowed out of her kitchen.

We learned well under her watchful eyebecause although there were differences in the spiciness of each pickle, they were all delicious.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (9)

Day 2 of cooking Green tomato pickles:

Draining off all the liquid from the tomato pickles mixture.

Boil a jug of hot water and pour over the green tomato mixture and drain again. Do this twice to remove all the salt.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (10)

Put the green tomatoes on the stove and add 450ml of white vinegar. Bring the mixture to the boil cover and then cook for ten minutes using a timer.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (11)

In the meantime in a bowl combine the flour, turmeric, and curry powder with the remaining 300mls vinegar until it becomes a paste. Reserve for later use.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (12)

When the tomato has boiled for ten minutes add the sugar and stir until dissolved.

Turn off the heat and add the paste slowly to the tomato mixture while stirring. Avoid lumps by adding the paste slowly and continuing to stir.

Once the relish paste has been fully combined, place the pickles over a low heat and simmer gently. Pickles should be cooked for another 10 minutes, or until the mixture has reached the desired consistency.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (13)

So thank you so much, Maureen, for sharing your famous green tomato pickles recipe and your time with me.

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (14)

Have you ever tasted or cooked something that instantly triggers a time in your life like the Green Tomato Pickles did for me?

Related

Green Tomato Pickles - Nan's Homemade Recipe - the BEST in town (2024)

FAQs

Why are my pickled green tomatoes mushy? ›

For this recipe, be sure to use unripe tomatoes, which stand up well to the pickling process. If growing your own, note that tomatoes picked after the first frost may be mushy, even if they look firm and green on the outside.

Why are my pickled green tomatoes bitter? ›

Maybe the green tomatoes you eat aren't all that underripe? If they were, you'd probably know. If you need to spice and pickle the tomatoes to make them taste good, then they're not ripe enough—solanine makes them taste bitter and horrible.

What tomatoes are best for pickling? ›

They also keep well in the fridge, so you can enjoy them for weeks or even months after pickling. If you're new to pickling, cherry tomatoes are a great place to start. They're easy to work with and produce a delicious result.

Is green tomato chutney made from unripe tomatoes? ›

Make use of end-of-season tomatoes with this sweet and vinegary green tomato chutney made with unripe tomatoes. Can it to enjoy all year long.

Why are my homemade pickles soft and mushy? ›

It may be a normal reaction during fermentation caused by bacteria. If the pickles are soft, they are spoiled from the yeast fermentation. Don't use them. Using too weak a salt brine or vinegar solution may cause soft or slippery pickles, as can using moldy garlic or storing the pickles at too warm a temperature.

How do you make pickles not mushy? ›

Add a Source of Tannin

Tannins work against softening enzymes and help keep pickles crunchier. They can be found in various sources, such as grape leaves, oak leaves, raspberry leaves, black tea, etc. Add some directly to your jars!

Why do my homemade pickles taste like vinegar? ›

Fermentation: The sour taste of pickles comes from the process of fermentation. During fermentation, naturally occurring bacteria (usually Lactobacillus) on the cucumbers consume the sugars present in them and convert them into lactic acid.

How do you reduce bitterness in tomato pickles? ›

Easy Ways to Reduce Bitter Taste in Any Food
  1. 1 Balance out bitterness with some fat.
  2. 2 Cover the flavor with sweetness.
  3. 3 Sprinkle some salt over your food.
  4. 4 Try a pinch of baking soda.
  5. 5 Squeeze in some vinegar or lemon juice.
  6. 6 Add some spice to your foods.
  7. 7 Cook with herbs to cut through the bitter taste.
Oct 22, 2023

Is it safe to eat unripe green tomatoes? ›

Green, thus unripe tomatoes contain a substance called tomatine in addition to solanine. Both tomatine and solanine are toxic so it is not wise to eat green tomatoes in large quantities. Solanine poisoning can cause unpleasant symptoms like fever, abdominal pain, diarrhea, vomiting, drowsiness and lethargy.

Is it safe to eat pickled green tomatoes? ›

Yes, you can eat pickled green tomatoes. They are a great way to use up green tomatoes that are starting to ripen and get too sweet to eat fresh. And they're also a good way to add some extra tartness and flavor to dishes. Pickling is a process of preserving food by either immersing it in brine (salt water) or vinegar.

What is the most important ingredient in pickling vegetables? ›

Vinegar is the most important ingredient in quick-pickle recipes. Without an adequate amount, the pickles will not be safe to eat. Use any vinegar with 5% acidity. Caution: Do not reduce the amount of vinegar or increase the amount of water in a recipe.

What kind of vinegar do you use for chutney? ›

Vinegar used in making chutney must be good quality and have at least 5% acetic acid content. Any good brand white, malt, wine or cider vinegar should possess the correct qualities. Brown sugar is used for darker coloured chutney but where a lighter colour is required granulated sugar is recommended.

Why do you only fry green tomatoes? ›

Unripe tomatoes are firmer and less juicy than their ripe counterparts. They are also tangier and milder in flavor, perfect for this batter fried treatment. At the end of the gardening season, tomatoes don't always have the warm weather needed to ripen.

What if tomato chutney is too runny? ›

If your chutney is too runny or your recipe calls for a thickening agent, always use cornflour mixed with a little of the vinegar. Cornflour is gluten free. Always to this at the very end because thickening your chutney like this will make catch and burn easily.

Why are my tomatoes soft and mushy? ›

Temperature fluctuations can cause mealy tomatoes. If the temperature drops too low at night, or if there are sudden changes in temperature, it can soften the texture of your tomatoes. The Solution: Keep a consistent temperature. Tomatoes like warm weather and consistent temperatures.

Why are my cherry tomatoes squishy? ›

Tomatoes, specifically cherry or grape varieties, can start to wrinkle and get soft when they're on the verge on going bad. They're perfectly edible but have lost some flavor and firmness, so they taste subpar.

Should green tomatoes be soft? ›

Harvest All Green Tomatoes at the End of the Season

"Harvest them when the fruit begins to change color and soften to the feel. At this point, most of the carbohydrates and sugars that will be sent to the fruit are already present in some form, but after-ripening indoors will enhance the flavor."

Are tomatoes still good if they are mushy? ›

A slight bruise won't hurt as you cook and prepare them, but a super-soft or moldy section is just no good," says Daigre.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6115

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-12-23

Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469

Phone: +494124489301

Job: Marketing Representative

Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking

Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.